This is rather a confusing book to read and I am deeply torn
about how I feel about it. It works really well as a historical novel looking
at the lives of a pair of uniquely fascinating 17th century characters.
Alongside this it makes clever use of extracts from 17th century writings
alongside contemporary interviews from 'celebrities' to provide a comparative
look at medical practice and the 'treatment' of ageing. This not only delves
into the bizarre ways in which some people are willing to treat signs of ageing,
but also shows that many of the weird and wonderful methods used historically
actually have enough basis in reality to continue to be used to this day. So as
a look into historic medical practice this works, and as a look into the
corrupt and slightly manic world of high society just prior to the revolution
and upheaval of civil war it also works, and works very well. Where I got a
little confused, and if I'm honest annoyed, was with the sections where the
modern world quite literally bleeds into the period narrative. You will be
happily reading about Sir Kenelm Digby's studies into alchemy and suddenly he
will start receiving messages from the future, in the form of mental text
messages or spam email. This makes the story seem a little disjointed and
slightly insane. I appreciate that the intention is to make Kenelm seem like a
man ahead of his time, but it just comes across as bizarre and jarring. I found
myself reading these sections rather more quickly than normal in order to
continue with the actual story. I think that this might genuinely cause this
book to do more poorly than it would otherwise; it comes across as essentially
a literary Knight's Tale (film not Chaucer extract). While there is a market
for properly quirky historic fiction, it is a lot more difficult to find, and
although I really hope that this will do as well as it deserves, I can see it
being a difficult one to pitch to prospective readers.
No comments:
Post a Comment